Sweet Pickle Relish Substitute (Alternative and Replacement)

If you love Sweet Pickle Relish but can’t find any in the grocery store, don’t worry – there are plenty of substitutes that will satisfy your craving without having to go on a special trip for it.

Before you start to get concerned, let us assure you that these alternatives taste just as good and deliver the same results when used in cooking.

Whether it’s because of personal preference or lack of availability – whatever the reason may be, we’ve got great recipes and ideas so you can still enjoy Sweet Pickle Relisheven if getting some at a store isn’t possible!

Read on to learn how these delicious replacements stack up against traditional pickle relish, plus how each can enhance your meals.

If you find yourself without the necessary ingredients to make your regular Sweet Pickle Relishdish, don’t worry.

There are plenty of equally delicious alternatives that you can use instead.

Try using finely chopped dill or sweet gherkin pickles as a replacement for the classic relish recipe.

If you want something even sweeter, try combining equal parts diced cucumbers and jalapeños with sugar or honey to create a sweet-and-spicy flavor.

For an altogether new taste experience, try subbing in diced mangoes or apricots for the pickle that is usually found in traditional relish recipes.

However you decide to adjust your recipe, there are bound to be some mouthwatering combinations that will surprise and delight your palate.

The best Sweet Pickle RelishSubstitutes, Alternatives, and Replacements

Sweet pickle relish, a condiment made of cucumber and sugar, adds unexpected, yet welcome sweetness to many dishes.

Unfortunately, Sweet Pickle Relishis not a staple in every pantry. However, there are several alternatives and replacements that can still provide that unique sweetness to enhance your culinary experience.

Try substituting grated apples into your dish for a fruity sweet flavor, or chopped dates for a more caramel-like taste.

If a pickled element is desired, try using dill pickles or cornichons as replacement vegetables as both provide tartness and crispiness.

Another great option is to increase your dish’s acidity levels with white vinegar or lemon juice for an extra zing of flavor!

What is Sweet Pickle Relish?

Sweet Pickle Relish is a condiment that is made with small cucumbers, peppers, onions, and a sweet vinegar mixture.

It adds zest to many dishes and its unmistakable tangy flavor makes any meal more exciting.

It can be used as a topping for hot dogs, hamburgers, or sandwiches, added to potato salad, macaroni salad, and tuna salads, and stirred into mayonnaise. It can be baked in casseroles like tuna noodles and bean bake or used as an ingredient in sauces.

Its bright yellow hue also adds color and eye appeal to dishes.

Sweet Pickle Relish is an inexpensive way of transforming mundane dishes into unique creations!

Nutritional facts and benefits of  Sweet Pickle Relish

Sweet Pickle Relish is a fantastic condiment that you can add to sandwiches, burgers, hotdogs, and more.

It’s made with cucumbers, onions, vinegar, and sugar, giving it a tart yet sweet flavor.

Not only is Sweet Pickle Relishdelicious but it also has some beneficial nutritional properties.

Its main ingredient is cucumber which provides essential vitamins and minerals like Vitamin K, Potassium, and Manganese.

In addition to the vitamins provided by cucumber, the relish contains Zinc from onions and fiber from both the cucumbers and onions.

This makes it an ideal snack or condiment for those looking for a nutritious way to enhance their meals.

How to choose the best substitute for  Sweet Pickle Relish

Choosing the best substitute for Sweet Pickle Relishcan be tricky, especially since product availability and quality vary from region to region.

The first step is to determine your exact needs, as there are both garnishing replacements and ingredient substitutes that result in different outcomes.

If you are looking for a garnishing sub, consider sauerkraut to turn up the flavor of burgers, hot dogs, and other picnic entrees.

On the other hand, general-purpose ingredients such as diced cucumber and onion mix provide a crunchy texture.

Before committing to any one product, however, it’s important to read the label carefully; look for those free of additional preservatives or artificial flavors when possible.

With these guidelines in mind, making necessary recipe adjustments should be relatively easy!

And here are some of the best substitutes for Sweet Pickle Relish

Chopped Dill Pickles

Chopped Dill Pickles are cucumbers that have been cut into small pieces.

This type of pickle is among the best substitutes for Sweet Pickle Relish because it contains many of the same ingredients and flavors while also offering a few unique additions that further enhance a dish’s overall taste.

Both Chopped Dill Pickles and Sweet Pickle Relish provide a crunchy texture and tangy, salty flavor profile, but the former also offers a hint of garlic as well as more herbaceous notes.

In general, you can use Chopped Dill Pickles as a direct substitute for Sweet Pickle Relish in any classic dish like macaroni or potato salad to help bring out some additional flavor.

Additionally, you can use them to enhance the taste of burgers, sandwiches, and various hot dogs in order to create an even tastier meal!

Green Olives

Green Olives and Sweet Pickle Relish are similar flavor profiles, thanks to the use of vinegar, salt, and spices in both products.

Both also have a tart, salty, and slightly sweet taste, making Green Olives an ideal substitute for Sweet Pickle Relish.

However, Green Olives come in several sizes, giving cooks greater freedom to add texture to enhance their recipes.

This primarily comes down to personal preference as small olives will provide a more intense olive flavor whereas larger olives will give a milder yet still flavorful experience.

When substituting Green Olives for Sweet Pickle Relish, it’s best to use smaller ones because the relish has finer pieces than most chopped olives.

Lastly, use them for classic dishes such as tuna and potato salads or accompanying sandwiches and wraps for more refreshment in your recipes!


Cucumbers offer a great substitute for Sweet Pickle Relish. But why is this?

The similarities between cucumber and Sweet Pickle Relish are that both are tart, crunchy, and full of flavor.

Despite these similarities, there are many differences between the two.

Sweet Pickle Relish has color and sweetness from added sugar, often with vinegar for sourness, which gives it a unique flavor compared to cucumbers.

Cucumbers can be chopped up or sliced thin and used as the perfect replacement in any dish calling for relish, particularly in salads or other cold recipes like potato salad.

When using cucumbers as a substitution you may want to add a bit more acid or chili flakes depending on how sweet you need your recipe to be!


Sauerkraut is an ideal substitute for Sweet Pickle Relish in many scenarios.

Both ingredients contain a combination of sour and salty flavors, which naturally complement some dishes.

Despite their similarities, Sauerkraut and Sweet Pickle Relish feature several distinct differences.

Generally, Sweet Pickle Relish has a sweeter taste than Sauerkraut, making it a more traditional condiment for hot dogs and sandwiches.

Sauerkraut features a crunchy texture, allowing it to stand out as a topping or side dish.

When substituting Sauerkraut, be mindful of its higher antioxidant content compared to Sweet Pickle Relish; this may affect the overall flavor profile and texture of the finished dish accordingly.

For example, in potato salads or casseroles one might use slightly less Sauerkraut than would be used for Sweet Pickle Relish to maintain a balance between the vegetable’s nutrient content and desired flavor.


Capers and Sweet Pickle Relish have many similarities but an important distinction: capers are a flower bud while Sweet Pickle Relish is a blend of fruits and/or vegetables.

Capers impart a sour, salty flavor with a burst of tanginess, similar to pickle relish.

However, due to its concentrated flavor, capers provide more intense taste than traditional Sweet Pickle Relish.

This makes them particularly good for when you need to season the dish in just one spoonful.

Capers are excellent for adding savory notes to light dishes like lemon shrimp pasta and roasted potatoes, as well as creamy salads such as potato salad and tuna salad.

They can be also used as a topping – put them in burgers or tacos where traditional add-ons such as ketchup or mustard provide too much sweetness.

But if your recipe calls for a more tart flavor, then use capers sparingly because they can turn out sharp and bitter if used too generously.

Green bell peppers

Green bell peppers are a great substitute for Sweet Pickle Relish due to the similarities in flavor as well as how both can add texture and flavor elements to a dish.

They both have a bright, acidic flavor that is slightly sweet and almost earthy with subtle grassy undertones.

While bell peppers tend to offer stronger colors, from green to red and yellow, they are much less salty than traditional pickle relish.

When substituting green bell pepper for Sweet Pickle Relish, it’s best to dice them into very small pieces – roughly the same size as traditional pickle relish – so they combine better into the overall dish.

This makes them terrific as part of salads, toppings on burgers or dogs, or as an added element in condiments like tartar sauce.

Freeze Dried Dill

Freeze Dried Dill is gaining traction as a viable substitute for Sweet Pickle Relish due to its similarities and versatility.

Both are comprised of minced cucumbers and are incredibly pungent with similar sweet, tart, and tangy flavors.

Perhaps the key benefit of freeze dried dill compared to relish is that it can retain its flavor better, particularly in dishes that require long cooking times.

Freeze dried dill has numerous uses thanks to it being lighter in texture and quicker to dissolve than standard pickles; they are an excellent substitute when making chowders, stuffing, sauces, or adding into marinades and salads.

To use freeze dried dill as a substitute for relish in recipes, try replacing teaspoon-per-teaspoon with any item containing fresh dill.

No doubt you’ll soon be singing the praises of this sublime accompaniment too!


Celery is often used as a great substitute for Sweet Pickle Relish in recipes.

The similarities between the two ingredients stem from their crunchy textures and mildly sweet taste.

Celery provides a mild yet distinct flavor to any dish it’s added to, which makes it a great substitute for sweet pickle relish.

Although celery tastes less salty than relish, the differences provide an advantage when making sandwiches or salads.

Celery works well when tossed into fish dishes or macaroni salad, and when diced finely, it can serve as an excellent substitution for diced cucumbers as well.

When swapping out Sweet Pickle Relishfor celery in a recipe, consider adding a bit of white vinegar and salt to create the familiar flavor of the original ingredient.

Sweet Gherkin Pickles

Sweet Gherkin pickles are also among the best substitutes for Sweet Pickle Relish due to their similar flavor profile and the versatility of uses.

Gherkins have a sour, salty, and slightly sweet flavor, making them comparable to Sweet Pickle Relishbut with a bit more of an acidic punch.

The biggest difference between the two is that Gherkin pickles are much smaller than traditional sweet pickles and come from cucumbers picked earlier in their growth cycle.

This means they are firmer but still crunchy when used as a substitute for sweet pickles in recipes calling for relish.

Gherkin pickles should be used as a topping in dishes like salads or burgers, or mixed into dips like tuna salad or egg salad for added texture, acidity, and flavor.

They are also often seen on sandwiches such as Italian beef and Reubens.

Green Tomato Relish

Green Tomato Relish is one of the best substitutes for Sweet Pickle Relish as it shares several similarities and can also bring some exciting variation to dishes.

Green Tomato Relish is made from green tomatoes, vinegar, onion, peppers, salt, and sugar; all similar ingredients found in Sweet Pickle Relishrecipes.

At the same time, green tomato relish stands apart in that it usually has more coarsely chopped ingredients and is spicier so those who love some extra zing may appreciate the difference.

To use green tomato relish as a substitute for sweet pickle relish, you are best off using it where you want its added kick – such as a condiment or part of a marinade – or when simply out of sweet pickle relish.

Piccalilli Relish

Piccalilli Relish is becoming increasingly popular as a versatile substitute for Sweet Pickle Relish.

Both types of relish share various similarities; they both contain vinegar, mustard, and sugar.

However, Piccalilli Relish also includes a variety of vegetables such as cauliflower, celery, onions and peppers, giving it a much more bold flavor.

This makes it the perfect addition to many dishes that call for more of an assertive taste profile.

For example, it can be added to hot dogs or sandwiches in place of Sweet Pickle Relish to provide significant flavor depth.

Additionally, Piccalilli Relish works well on deli dishes like potato salads or macaroni salads that need more flavor balance than what Sweet Pickle Relishalone can bring.

All in all, Piccalilli Relish is an excellent substitution for Sweet Pickle Relishanytime you want some zing in your dish!


Chutney is an excellent substitute for Sweet Pickle Relishin recipes and sauces.

Both condiments have similar flavor elements, such as sweet and tangy, so swapping them out will not drastically alter the taste.

Unlike Sweet Pickle Relish, Chutney has a savory rather than a sharp flavor due to its inclusion of spices like cumin and coriander.

When using Chutney as a substitute for Sweet Pickle relish, it is best to pick one that matches the original recipe’s sweetness level side-by-side with the desired savory tones.

For dishes where there already is abundant seasoning, use a spicier chutney alternative so that the flavors will balance out adequately.

Apple Butter

Apple butter is one of the best substitutes for Sweet Pickle Relishdue to its similar texture, sweetness, and tanginess.

Both are thick and sticky condiments with a unique flavour profile which makes them quite versatile.

The main difference between apple butter and Sweet Pickle Relishis simply their main ingredient; apple and cucumber respectively.

Apple butter has more depth of flavour from its cinnamon, nutmeg, and allspice spicing whereas Sweet Pickle Relishhas a simpler taste from vinegar, sugar, salt, mustard seeds, turmeric and celery seed.

When appropriate you can use apple butter as a substitution in many recipes that call for pickle relish such as hotdogs or burgers or dips like tartar sauce.

You may also decide to use it in place if applesauce or jam on items like pancakes or ice cream sundaes to add an interesting yet familiar sweetness.

Can you make Sweet Pickle Relish at home?

Homemade Sweet Pickle Relish is a delicious condiment that you can easily make from the comfort of your own home.

All you’ll need is cucumbers, onions, red bell pepper, celery seed, white vinegar, sugar, salt, and mustard seed and you’re ready to get started.

Whether you love to put it on hamburgers or hotdogs or even fish tacos, this easy-to-make recipe is sure to leave your taste buds tingling with satisfaction.

While it does take some time to have everything ready for serving, the rewards are well worth it when you get to enjoy the homemade product!

Recipe  for homemade Sweet Pickle Relish

Making Sweet Pickle Relish at home is a great way to add a delicious, homemade condiment to your meal.

Start by gathering the ingredients like pickling cucumbers, onions, bell peppers, sugar, and vinegar.

Next, dice the cucumber and onion into small pieces and cut the bell pepper into large chunks before combining them in a medium bowl with sugar.

Mix in the vinegar thoroughly until all of the vegetables are evenly coated. Put this mixture in the refrigerator for 1-2 hours to become a relish consistency. Serve as desired and enjoy!

No matter what type of pickle or relish you enjoy in your recipes, it’s important to find a substitute when the ingredients are unavailable.

While this Sweet Pickle Relish alternative can serve well in most recipes, there are other options to consider if you don’t have success with this recipe.

Simply subbing in dill relish can be a quick and easy solution, but for more adventurous cooks, try substituting horseradish or diced jalapenos for some extra kick!

With these alternatives in hand, you won’t have to miss out on the flavorful addition of pickles and relishes in your meals anymore.

If all else fails, don’t forget that there’s always a jar of store-bought pickle relishes hiding among the condiments in your pantry!

More topics to discover:

Please Like & Share This Article:

Recent Posts